[blindlaw] Blind lawyer: Pro took me for 8G
Rod Alcidonis
roddj12 at hotmail.com
Sat Oct 3 09:49:16 UTC 2009
Blind lawyer: Pro took me for 8G
By STEPHANIE FARR
Philadelphia Daily News
farrs at phillynews.com
215-854-4225
Whether it was prostitution or Pilates, a blind Delaware County lawyer is hoping for a happy ending after his federal civil suit against a Philadelphia
woman and a credit-card company was thrown out last week.
John F. Peoples, 60, was steamed after he learned that the woman who he says he hired for sex allegedly overbilled his Discover card by $8,600.
So he sued her for damages and the credit-card company for alleged violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act, claiming that it had not sufficiently
protected its blind customers.
"This wouldn't have happened to a sighted person," Peoples said yesterday, adding that he plans to appeal.
In court documents, the woman named in the suit, Ginger Dayle, said that she had provided Pilates lessons to Peoples and denied that she was a prostitute
or that she had defrauded his credit card.
She filed a countersuit claiming that Peoples had inappropriately touched her butt and that he initiated the lawsuit after she rebuffed his sexual advances,
according to court documents.
That case also was dismissed.
Peoples, 60, of Broomall, who has been legally blind since birth, claims to have met Dayle through an escort-services Web site.
He said that he had sessions with her about every other week for six months in 2007 at $275 to $375 an hour.
He said that he charged the sessions to his Discover card and signed a receipt - which he couldn't see - that Dayle told him had the agreed-upon amount
- usually $750 for two hours.
But on 11 occasions, Dayle actually charged him $1,100 and in one case $1,600, "knowing he was blind and could not see he was being tricked," according
to court records.
Peoples also claimed that she had forged his signatures on slips for days that did not use her services.
He said that he realized the alleged fraud only when his mother read him his credit-card bill.
When Peoples reported the alleged fraud to Discover, it failed to take any action, court documents said.
In his suit, he cited the Americans with Disabilities Act, claiming that Discover does not provide "reasonable accommodations" for blind consumers to use
their services without running the risk of being defrauded by merchants.
In his initial complaint, Peoples did not allege that Dayle was a prostitute, saying only that she "advertises herself as an expert at providing personal,
hands-on service to individual customers in private sessions at a set rate," according to court documents.
It was only during his deposition in October 2008, that he first stated that those services were prostitution, court documents said.
When asked during deposition if he ever, as a lawyer, thought twice about using a prostitute, he said, according to court documents: "It doesn't bother
me because it doesn't affect my practice of law. Prostitution, I believe, is a misdemeanor. Even if convicted, it would not be a problem for the disciplinary
board."
In an interview yesterday, Peoples said that many blind men "get stuck" using prostitutes because it's hard to meet women.
"If you go to a singles bar with a stick in your hand, you're not going to be attacked by women," he said. "Women aren't too interested in blind men."
He said that he had the chutzpah
to bring the suit because he figured this was the only way to "make her pay."
"They figure nobody will do anything to them and people will be too embarrassed, and that's why this happens," he said.
Dayle, who bills herself as a fitness instructor, professional dancer, actor and an adjunct professor, denied being a prostitute in court documents.
When reached yesterday, she declined to comment except to say that the case was "bad publicity." She referred all questions to her attorney, William Reil,
who did not return calls for comment.
Peoples said that Dayle's claims that she had provided him with Pilates lessons were "ridiculous."
"I have arthritis, diabetes and chronic fatigue syndrome," he said.
In court documents, he said that he was "barely able to walk, let alone do Pilates" and that sex is "one of the few exercises I get to do."
In his memorandum, U.S. District Judge Edmund Ludwig dismissed Peoples' claim against Discover and said that he couldn't recover his disputed charges because
they were for an illegal and "prohibited transaction," which constituted a breach of the card-member agreement.
Ludwig also said in court documents that the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) did not apply in the case because it refers only to a "public accommodation."
Martin C. Bryce Jr., an attorney for Discover on the case, explained: "The use of a credit card in this instance did not fall under the ADA because the
ADA applies to places and a credit card is not a place," he said.
Peoples said that he was upset that the statute had been interpreted not to include credit-card companies.
"I don't think the people who designed the ADA and put it into words expected credit-card companies not to help us," he said. "This denies the blind access
to credit cards. If you can be cheated, then you can't use credit cards."
Buzz up!
Buzz this story.
CURRENTLY SHOWING ON PHILLY.COM
images/090325_pc_dish_203_kan_1
The Philly Dish: Cooking over a wood fire at Alba
images/090923_pc_puc_elvez_1
Philly Uncorked: Spicy Spanish Garnacha
images/090922_pc_MOB_Poker100
Mob Scene: Video Poker
images/092909-sixr-100
76ers open training camp
images/090911_pc_DTS_Sep_100
Down the Shore: Julie and Emily savor September
PEOPLE WHO READ THIS ALSO READ
definition list of 5 items
Jury awards $100 million to children of slain elderly couple
15-to-30 for killing man who saved his life
Pizza-eating police nab three suspected thieves
Harry Gross: Wife has inherit rights
Convicted drug dealer testifies against friend
list end
...AND BOUGHT:
Antibacterial Lotion Soap 800ml Bag...
SamsClub.com
52" Philips LCD 1080p HDTV 120hz
SamsClub.com
Pet Jogger
SamsClub.com
logos/DiscoveryByPique_FFFFFF
list of 4 items
Jobs
Cars
Real Estate
Rentals
list end
Flash movie start
System Administrator
FEATURED VIDEO:
top
jobs
To View Videos...
Sr. Adpe Engineer
Unlabeled 7
Please click on a job description to the right.
Supervisor
Unlabeled 10
Unlabeled 11
Teller Supervisor, Sr Staff Accountant, Bank Operations Accounting Clerk
JOB DETAILS
Unlabeled 15
Unlabeled 16
Therapist
Unlabeled 18
Flash movie end
View all Top Jobs »
SEARCH JOBS
find »
Sponsored Links
Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance
($200,000 Refinance under $1,059/mo) See Rates - No Credit Check Req.
SeeRefinanceRates.com
Obama Wants You to Return to School
Get Your Degree Now. Financial Aid & Scholarships are available.
www.classesusa.com
Refinance Now at 4.25% Fixed
$160,000 Mortgage for $633/mo. Free. No obligation. Get 4 quotes.
MortgageRefinance.LendGo.com
Advertise Here
MOST POPULAR PHILLY.COM PHOTOS
images/20091001_zombieprom_90
Philly Zombie Prom
images/james_coleman_b_90
Cold Cases, Vanishings
images/20090830_sexysingle_90
2009 Sexy Singles + Party
images/20090922_nakedbikeride_90
Philly Naked Bike Ride
images/mtbambooinna16_promo
Making Time Pool Party
images/20080830_lingerieFB_90
Lingerie Football
Daily Headlines
Subscribe now! Daily Headlines Newsletter
Your email address:
Already a philly.com member?
Yes
No
SUBSCRIBE
Philly.com news blogs
Beck to the future?
Attytood Will Bunch
Riffs and tiffs
American Debate Dick Polman
Good Morning Philadelphia: Everyone's seeing pink
Inquirer From the Source From the Source
Arts Tax Opponents Hopeful
Philly Clout Chris Brennan and Catherine Lucey
Philly.com news columnists
definition list of 1 items
Healing hands for 'a connector'
By Daniel Rubin, Inquirer Columnist
Blinq: Harry Sefarbi, RIP. A Link to Barnes.
designimages/spacer
list end
Mayors' group comes...
By Monica Yant Kinney, Inquirer Columnist
>From deli to dollars, Dietz & Watson is a treasure
No more Columbus parade snafus, vows Sons of Italy
list of 2 items
Viewed
Shared
list end
definition list of 10 items
Paul Domowitch: Gruden likes Wildcat, but not with Eagles
Blind lawyer: Pro took me for 8G
CBS worker arrested in Letterman blackmail plot
TD Bank scrambles to fix computer problems
Phillies Notes: Manuel hints of Phillies' playoff rotation
Thief holds knife to tot's neck, slashes teen
Raids target knock-offs on South Street
Suit filed by Hudson River air-crash victim's widow
Pizza-eating police nab three suspected thieves
High School Sport Score Board
list end
»
More Most Viewed
today's Philly.com poll
Are you...
Getting excited about the Phillies again
Still uncertain about the Eagles
Ready for the Sixers
Strictly a Flyers fan
Watching the mailbox for your Philadelphia Union season tickets
View results
Vote
definition list of 6 items
XML
TODAY'S PHILLY.COM VIDEOS
Sudoku on the Rails
Hoarder charged with animal cruelty
Deep Sixer Playlist
Penn State videos
Kate Gosselin to go solo
More videos »
designimages/spacer
list end
Philly.com Promotions
definition list of 7 items
Flourish
Philly.com Contests
Philadelphia Visitors Guide
Philadelphia Business Today
Philadelphia Restaurants
Philadelphia Sports
Philly.com Twitter Directory
list end
definition list of 6 items
latest photo galleries
Marlins 7, Phils 2
Northeast 14, Washington 12
St. Joe's Prep 28, Judge 21
Eustace 28, Cinnaminson 20
Flyers 2, Hurricanes 0
D'town East 32, Avon Grove 21
designimages/spacer
list end
C & S CONTRACTORS
ROOFING SALE -- All Types Of Roofs -- 215-332-6600
SUPREME BUFFET & GRILL
101 S. 69TH STREET IN UPPER DARBY, PA
Lisa/Eric Poppel Majestic Productions
The Ultimate Collectibles Show Oct. 3rd & 4th The Greater Phila Expo Center Oaks PA 200+ dealer tables and 125 autograph guests each day
PHILA. PUBLIC AUTO AUCTION
Wed. and Sat. Auctions - 57th & Woodland Ave. - 215-730-9922
Broadview Kitchen & Bath
Check out our year round specials
Philly.com:
definition list of 1 items
News
|
Sports |
Business |
What's Happening |
Restaurants & Food |
Entertainment |
Living |
Marketplace |
Jobs
list end
Site Services:
definition list of 1 items
Advertise on Philly.com
|
View print ads and special sections
|
Mobile Edition
|
The e-Inquirer
|
Join Our Team
|
News In Education
list end
The Inquirer:
definition list of 1 items
News
|
Front Page |
Sports |
Business |
Obituaries |
Arts & Entertainment |
Food, Home & Life |
Health & Science |
Education |
Opinion |
Blogs & Columns |
Subscriber Services
list end
Daily News:
definition list of 1 items
City & Local
|
Sports |
Yo! Features |
Columnists |
Daily News Opinion |
Photos |
Multimedia |
National News |
Obituaries |
Subscriber Services
list end
Classifieds:
definition list of 1 items
Jobs
|
Cars
|
More information about the BlindLaw
mailing list