[humanser] Blind Psychologist on Blind Simulations

[Merry Schoch]

Thank you, JD for sending out this information. I was impressed this week that the "Seeing Eye" distributed this article and I give them "Kudos" for that!  Hope you are well, JD and I am always pleased to receive articles and information that you share.

With warmest regards,
Merry C. Schoch, LCSW

-----Original Message-----
From: HumanSer [mailto:humanser-bounces at nfbnet.org] On Behalf Of JD Townsend via HumanSer
Sent: Sunday, October 23, 2016 10:47 PM
To: Human Services Mailing List
Cc: JD Townsend
Subject: [humanser] Blind Psychologist on Blind Simulations



Blindfolding Doesn't Help People Understand What It's Like to be Blind

list of 1 items

Over a year ago 

list end

 by 

NATALIE SHOEMAKER

Article Image 



“You never truly know someone until you've walked a mile in their shoes.” It's an old adage that speaks for humanity to experience or imagine another person's

situation in order to understand. Put on a blindfold, for instance, and you'll instantly know what it's like to be blind. Perhaps not, according to one

study.



Ben Richmond from Motherboard

 writes on a 

recent study

 that shows people who experience simulated blindness perceive blind people as less capable. The lead study's author Arielle Silverman, who is a PhD candidate

at CU-Boulder's Department of Psychology and Neuroscience (and blind), spoke to Richmond in an interview, saying:



block quote

“Disability activists have long argued that simulations give a falsely negative view of disability.”

block quote end



This view may give some the impression that blind folks are less capable than those with sight. In order to prove this hypothesis, Silverman and her team

gathered 100 student participants. Some of the participants were blindfolded and asked to perform simple tasks from walking down a hallway to sorting coins.

At the study's conclusion, 53 percent of participants who were blindfolded came away with the impression that blind people are less capable. Where only

34 percent of people who were not blindfolded thought the same. 



block quote

“Participants' attitudes were harmed because the blindfolded experience led them to believe that blind people cannot perform activities as well as people

with normal vision. While all participants tended to have this belief, it was more intense among the participants who had just simulated blindness.”

block quote end



Of course, Silverman disagrees with this notion. Technology has come a long way, she says, allowing the disabled to perform some duties without the need

of an  assistant.



The issue that concerns her most is that blindness simulations are often used as educational tools for students and teachers--without first consulting

a blind person. If participants are coming away with the notion that the blind are less able than people with sight, then these “blind simulations” don't

adequately represent their true abilities. Her fear is that this perception could create a misunderstanding that could hinder someone from gaining access

to certain jobs where managers may think the applicant wouldn't be able to carry out their duties adequately. 



block quote

“In my view, any educational exercise about disability should be guided first and foremost by people with disabilities, and these individuals should be

front and center in delivering the exercise to students. If simulations are used at all, they should be crafted so as to present participants with a balanced

perspective on the positive, negative and neutral aspects of having a lifelong disability.”

block quote end



Read more at 

Motherboard





JD Townsend LCSW
Helping the light dependent to see.
Daytona Beach, Earth, Sol System