[nabs-l] Blindness versus minority groups

[Marc Workman]

Hi Tara,

I really feel like your message demonstrates just how deeply you've internalized the notion that sight is right and blindness is ugliness.  I think it's a terrible message to spread.

Examples:

Tara wrote,
> A blind person can still appear "normal" without knowing all of these movements.  It is more important for a blind person to get rid of strange movements than to learn "normal" body language.

Since when does normal equal good, or better, or right? Normal is a statistical concept that we have unfortunately and mistakenly injected with the idea that normal is better than not normal.  By strange movements, I assume you mean movements that the average sighted person does not make.  Why exactly is it so important that blind people try to look and act like some sighted people? Is it also the case that non-whites should look and act like whites?

Tara wrote,
> Another area that some blind people   need to improve upon is dress.  It is better for blind to wear sunglasses if their eyes are  deformed--it will help  the general public be at ease when communicating.

This one I find even more disturbing.  I'm sure we'd all be more at ease if we all looked and acted the same, but that does not mean it something worth striving for.  I would much rather live in a world where someone's looking different didn't make others so uneasy than in a world where we encourage people to hide their differences in order to make others more comfortable.

I could go on, but I think my point has been made.  I hope that blind people do not believe that failing to look and act like the average sighted person means we are ugly, strange, weird, wrong and otherwise inferior.  I completely reject that notion.

Regards,

Marc
On 2011-11-18, at 11:55 AM, Tara Annis wrote:

> Arielle, I do think totally blind from birth can improve on nonverbal communication.  I'm not sure if all could get as good as sighted, but I would  say like any skill, each blind person would achieve their own level of progress.  I do agree with stiffness--a lot of nonverbal communication is done very quickly and in a kind of lazy manner with the hands at a relaxed position.  I'm shocked at all that is communicated; I recently learned there is a hand movement  for so-so or all right, as in how was your work day and the person would use this gesture as they verbally say it was all right or okay or so-so.  
> 
> A blind person can still appear "normal" without knowing all of these movements.  It is more important for a blind person to get rid of strange movements than to learn "normal" body language.  It is absolutely necessary to  get rid of rocking, inappropriate facial expression for the  situation being experienced (smiling at a funeral), etc. A blind person can have stiff movements, but still  appear "normal"  
> What is really needed   is a sighted person to evaluate each blind person on an individual basis, and be honest enough to tell if there are any totally weird movements.  According to the comments on Youtube, Ken Jennings the  blind guy on Jeopardy, had weird facial expressions, so  this seems to be a common problem.
> 
> I think some blind people need to learn more about manners, as in move to the side of the aisle in a grocery store when another person with a cart walks by,  do not stop at the top of stairs or escalators, and do not stop when entering  the doorway  of a business.  Also, some tend to cut people off in  crowds or push people  out of the way.  While I know it is  almost impossible not to fix this completely, I've met people who do not even try and get better at their O&M. I've been around blind people that will shove people  out of their way at the mall, or push a door open when there are people standing on the other side of it.  They told me, "it is sighted people's responsibility to watch out for me and I don't have to do anything on my part cause I'm blind."  
> 
> Another area that some blind people   need to improve upon is dress.  It is better for blind to wear sunglasses if their eyes are  deformed--it will help  the general public be at ease when communicating.  Also, some blind wear clothes that are not in fashion.  I've seen parents give their children "simple" haircuts, buzz cut or shaved head for their son and a really short bob for girls, since they feel the  child cannot  learn to  take care of long hair.  (I hate when this  happens.)  I'd also like to see more blind kids dress for their peer group, such as emo or goth, hippie, skater, preppie, average person, etc.  
> 
> I'm not making fun of people with these traits, I just feel they need the truth.  While I think  people  should not be judged for their appearance, many people in the world do act this way, though sometimes it is subconscious.
> 
> _______________________________________________
> nabs-l mailing list
> nabs-l at nfbnet.org
> http://nfbnet.org/mailman/listinfo/nabs-l_nfbnet.org
> To unsubscribe, change your list options or get your account info for nabs-l:
> http://nfbnet.org/mailman/options/nabs-l_nfbnet.org/mworkman.lists%40gmail.com