[nfbmi-talk] a worthy repost from nfbblindtalk

joe harcz Comcast joeharcz at comcast.net
Sat Apr 24 23:19:30 UTC 2010

No Jews Allowed


[Blindtlk] No Jews Allowed

list end

Dear All,

I was asked to circulate this message by Marc Dubin, Mr. Dubin is a subscriber to the email list of the National Association of Guide Dog Users. Marc is

a former Senior Trial Attorney with the United States department of Justice and currently serves as the Director of Advocacy for the Center for Independent

Living of South Florida, located in Miami, and

Chairs the Florida Bar's Disability Law Committee


. I hope everyone will take the time to read his comments, as I believe they will help put our work as advoacates into perspective!


Fraternally yours,

Marion Gwizdala, President

National Association of Guide Dog Users

National Federation of the Blind




No Jews Allowed


By Marc Dubin, Esq.


mdubin at pobox.com



Imagine that you sought help from the police after being beaten by your husband, only to find that you were told that you could not receive their services

because you are Jewish.


Imagine that you sought the services of the domestic violence program but are told that you could not receive their services because you are Jewish.


Imagine that you sought the services of the Red Cross during a Hurricane but are told that you could not receive their services because you are Jewish.


Imagine that you are the victim of rape, and sought the services of the rape treatment service but are told that you could not receive their services because

you are Jewish.


Imagine that you desperately need medical care but are told that you could not see the doctor because you are Jewish.


Imagine that you went shopping, and are unable to go into a grocery store because you are Jewish.


And imagine that you seek out the services of an attorney, and are denied services because you are Jewish.


You would be outraged, and hurt. You would find allies to join you in protest. You would seek to have anti-discrimination laws enforced. You would consider

suing. You would wonder how in this day and age such discrimination could occur.


Every day, people with disabilities seek the services of law enforcement, domestic violence programs, Red Cross Shelters, rape treatment programs, health

care providers, businesses, attorneys, and others, and are denied services because they have a disability. Architectural barriers that should not exist

remain. Sign language interpreters are not provided. Policies that should be changed are not changed, and these policies prevent people with disabilities

from using the services they need. Written materials are not offered in alternative formats. Service animals are excluded.


If you are a person with a disability, these scenarios are all too familiar. You recognize these denials for what they are  - civil rights violations. These

denials are as offensive, as hurtful, as harmful as signs saying No Jews Allowed.


My family understands this all too well. I am Jewish. When my parents were growing up, they were kicked out of school, for being Jewish.. Their parents

were no longer allowed to work, because they were Jewish. They were beaten up by their neighbors, because they were Jewish. They could not shop in the

neighborhood grocery stores, because they were Jewish. And, they were arrested, along with every other member of their family, because they were Jewish.


Yes, it was another time and place. It was Poland, and Hitler was coming to power. Discrimination was all around them, and grew, and grew.


I believe that I am well aware of the cost of social injustice and of the abuse of power,  . My parents instilled in me an awareness of the importance of

public service, the cost of prejudice and abuse of power, and of the debt I owe.


Both of my parents came to the United States in 1952, from Lodz, Poland. My parents were both survivors of Hitler's concentration camps, and were the only

members of their respective families to survive.(They each had 7 brothers and sisters) Before the war, Lodz had the second largest Jewish community in

Europe. As of 1939, there were 230,000 Jews in Lodz. The Germans moved them all into one area of the city, and walled it off. Eventually, an additional

25,000 people were brought in (20,000 Jews, and 5,000 Gypsies). The Germans then systematically starved and killed them.


Beginning in January of 1942, the Germans began transporting Jews from Lodz to the Chelmno death camp, at a rate of approximately 1,000 a day. Within 3

weeks, over 10,000 people had been transported. Between February and April of 1942, over 34,000 more were taken away and killed. These deportations continued

month after month. In August 1944, the ghetto was closed, and all remaining residents were transported by train to Auschwitz. My parents and some members

of their families were among this group.


As of 1944, of the original 250,000 Jews in Lodz, 30,000 were still alive.. Shortly before the end of the war, on January 18, 1945, the Germans removed

66,000 Jews from Auschwitz, and in an effort to avoid discovery by the Soviet Army, which was advancing toward the camp, marched them in the snow for days,

and shot them as they marched, trying to destroy the evidence of what they had done. My father was on this death march, but escaped by leading a group

of prisoners into the forest, emerging only when the Soviet Army arrived.


By the time they were liberated from Auschwitz at the end of the war, in January 1945, only 15,000 of the original 250,000 jews in Lodz had survived. An

estimated 1, 500,000 Jews were killed at Auschwitz. All of my parents' families, including their parents, their grandparents, their cousins, their uncles,

their aunts, their sisters, and their brothers, were killed.


Upon their liberation from Auschwitz, my parents were sent to a Displaced Persons camp, where they were kept for seven years. My sister was born in and

spent the first six years of her life in the Displaced Persons Camp. In 1952, my parents emigrated to the United States.


I tell you this because it is essential that we understand that the discrimination we address on behalf of people with disabilities is about civil rights,

and about what we as a nation stand for when it comes to ensuring equal opportunity. When someone in a wheelchair is denied access to shelter, or access

to government services, or access to civic life, they are experiencing discrimination. When someone who is deaf or hard of hearing is denied access to

health care because a doctor refuses to pay for a qualified sign language interpreter, they are experiencing discrimination. When someone who is blind

is denied access to written materials in accessible format, they are experiencing discrimination. Let’s not be unclear about this. The denial of civil

rights is the first step toward seeing people with disabilities as inferior, and the first step to allowing the kind of thinking that can lead us down

a very dangerous path. When the Nazis came to power, the first group killed were people with disabilities. It is essential that we understand the parallels,

and that when we see discrimination, we stand up to it, and that we ally ourselves with its victims. We need not see signs saying “No People with Disabilities

 Allowed” to understand that discrimination is occurring, and that we need to do what we can, what we must, to remove those invisible, yet powerful signs.

Lack of intent is not the test. The test is whether the discrimination occurs, and whether we have the will to overcome the discrimination. I believe we

do, if we work together, and if we have the will to identify the discrimination for what it is.


Reproduction of this article is encouraged.






Marc Dubin, Esq.


Director of Advocacy, Center for Independent Living of South Florida


mdubin at pobox.com



Mobile: 305-896-3000


Fax: 877-731-3030




Chair, Florida Bar Disability Law Committee





Former Senior Trial Attorney, U.S. Department of Justice 1993-2005   www.ada.gov


Former Special Counsel, Office on Violence Against Women, USDOJ




Founder & Executive Director, CAVNET    www.cavnet.org




ADA Expertise is owned and operated by Marc Dubin, Esq. Opinions posted are posted in a private capacity, and are not to be construed to be the opinions

of the CIL, its employees, Board, or volunteers.


ADAExpertise | Archives | Modify Your Subscription



More information about the NFBMI-Talk mailing list