[nfbwatlk] Fwd: [Wcb-l] Superpowers for the Blind and Deaf The brain rewires itselfto boost the remaining senses

Thu Sep 20 18:53:00 UTC 2012

Wonder what Dr. Fein thinks about this article.  She's been working on research on the visual cortex. I agree with you Mike, much of the "enhancement" may be because of learned sensory information, or use of the other senses without the use of the lost ones. 

The statement that always makes me nuts is about the examples of Stevie Wunder and Ray Charles as great musicians, and their blindness is cited as perhaps part of the reason.  How about all , and I mean the *overwhelming number of * musicians that are not sensory impaired at all. So why are Stevie and Ray singled out, just because of their blindness. Would the others be even more amazing if they were blind.

/s/

Bennett 
-----Original Message-----
From: nfbwatlk-bounces at nfbnet.org [mailto:nfbwatlk-bounces at nfbnet.org] On Behalf Of Mike Freeman
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 3:32 PM
To: NFB of Washington Talk Mailing List
Subject: [nfbwatlk] Fwd: [Wcb-l] Superpowers for the Blind and Deaf The brain rewires itselfto boost the remaining senses

The article appears below Sarah's message. 

In my opinion, the mistake the article's authors make is to assume that brain plasticity and increased activity in certain areas results in increased acuity or function. How can one truly distinguish organically between increased acuity due to learning and practice and increased acuity due to real increased brain function? How can one truly factor out the stereotypes and biases of the scientists? What would have happened had the scientists devised experiments designed specifically to tease out the influence of learning on the behavior they observe rather then assuming their work confirmed the usual stereotypes we live with every day? For example, did the scientists study tone-deaf blind persons? I suspect not. 

Once again, critical thinking takes a dive to stereotypes! 

Mike 

Begin forwarded message:

> From: "Sarah E" <countrygirl at ultraemail.us>
> Date: September 19, 2012 13:00:31 PDT
> To: "Carl Jarvis" <carjar82 at gmail.com>, "wcb" <Wcb-l at wcbinfo.org>
> Subject: Re: [Wcb-l] Superpowers for the Blind and Deaf The brain rewires itselfto boost the remaining senses
> 
> Interesting!  No, absolutely fascinating!  I always wondered why the more hearing I lose, the more I can "Feel," things and large objects, with the nerves in my face.  At least, I think that's what stops me from hitting walls.  So, it sounds like I won't lose my mobility, if I lose more hearing?
> Sarah Edick-Howe
> ----- Original Message ----- From: "Carl Jarvis" <carjar82 at gmail.com>
> To: "wcb" <Wcb-l at wcbinfo.org>
> Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 6:43 AM
> Subject: [Wcb-l] Superpowers for the Blind and Deaf The brain rewires itselfto boost the remaining senses
> 
> 
>> cross-modal plasticity.
>> Say that three times with your eyes crossed and then read this interesting
>> article.
>> Carl Jarvis
>> ***
>> 
>> Superpowers for the Blind and Deaf
>> The brain rewires itself to boost the remaining senses
>> 
>> By Mary Bates  | Tuesday, September 18, 2012
>> 
>> It's a bird, it's a plane...
>> 
>> Image: iStock/ Kriss Russell
>> 
>> Advertisement
>> It's an oft-repeated idea that blind people can compensate for their
>> lack of sight with enhanced hearing or other abilities. The musical
>> talents of Stevie Wonder and Ray Charles, both blinded at an early
>> age, are cited as examples of blindness conferring an advantage in
>> other areas. Then there's the superhero Daredevil, who is blind but
>> uses his heightened remaining senses to fight crime.
>> 
>> It is commonly assumed that the improvement in the remaining senses is
>> a result of learned behavior; in the absence of vision, blind people
>> pay attention to auditory cues and learn how to use them more
>> efficiently. But there is mounting evidence that people missing one
>> sense don't just learn to use the others better. The brain adapts to
>> the loss by giving itself a makeover. If one sense is lost, the areas
>> of the brain normally devoted to handling that sensory information do
>> not go unused — they get rewired and put to work processing other
>> senses.
>> 
>> A new study provides evidence of this rewiring in the brains of deaf
>> people. The study, published in The Journal of Neuroscience, shows
>> people who are born deaf use areas of the brain typically devoted to
>> processing sound to instead process touch and vision. Perhaps more
>> interestingly, the researchers found this neural reorganization
>> affects how deaf individuals perceive sensory stimuli, making them
>> susceptible to a perceptual illusion that hearing people do not
>> experience.
>> 
>> These new findings are part of the growing research on
>> neuroplasticity, the ability of our brains to change with experience.
>> A large body of evidence shows when the brain is deprived of input in
>> one sensory modality, it is capable of reorganizing itself to support
>> and augment other senses, a phenomenon known as cross-modal
>> neuroplasticity.
>> 
>> Understanding how the brain rewires itself when a sense is lost has
>> implications for the rehabilitation of deaf and blind individuals, but
>> also for understanding when and how the brain is able to transform
>> itself. Researchers look to the brains of the deaf and blind for clues
>> about the limits of brain plasticity and the mechanisms underlying it.
>> So far, it appears that some brain systems are not very plastic and
>> cannot be changed with experience. Other systems can be modified by
>> experience but only during particular sensitive periods (as is the
>> case with language acquisition). Finally, some neural systems remain
>> plastic and can be changed by experience throughout life. Discovering
>> factors that promote brain plasticity will impact several areas: how
>> we educate normally developing as well as blind and deaf children;
>> rehabilitation after brain injury; and the treatment (and possible
>> reversal) of neurodegenerative diseases and age-related decline.
>> 
>> Most of the research on cross-modal neuroplasticity has focused on
>> blind individuals, who often have enhanced auditory abilities. Brain
>> imaging studies show the visual cortex in the blind is taken over by
>> other senses, such as hearing or touch, and contributes to language
>> processing. However, researchers do not know as much about how
>> deafness changes the auditory cortex. Helen Neville, one of the
>> authors of the new study, previously showed people born deaf are
>> better at processing peripheral vision and motion. Some animal studies
>> indicate both vision and touch play a role in altered cross-modal
>> organization of auditory cortex, but until now, the evidence in humans
>> has been limited.
>> 
>> In the new study, Christina Karns, Neville, and Mark Dow of the
>> University of Oregon asked how the early loss of hearing affected
>> neuroplasticity in the deaf brain, and if that reorganization
>> translated to altered perceptual abilities in deaf people. They were
>> especially interested to see if deafness would affect how the brain
>> processes touch and vision together, a question that had not been
>> answered before now because it required precise tactile stimuli. Karns
>> and her co-authors designed a unique device worn like headphones by
>> the study's participants while inside an fMRI scanner. Flexible
>> tubing, connected to a compressor in an adjacent room, delivered puffs
>> of air to precise locations on participants' faces. These served as
>> the tactile stimuli. Visual stimuli — brief pulses of light — were
>> delivered through fiber optic cables mounted directly below the
>> air-puff nozzle.
>> 
>> The researchers used the fMRI scanner to monitor changes in blood flow
>> to different areas of the brain, with increased blood flow indicating
>> an increase in brain activity. They paid special attention to an area
>> known as Heschl's gyrus, which is the site of the primary auditory
>> cortex in the human brain.
>> 
>> The participants included 13 congenitally deaf adults and 12 hearing
>> adults for comparison. The deaf participants had more activation in
>> the auditory cortex in response to touch and visual stimuli than did
>> the hearing participants. Karns and her colleagues were surprised to
>> find the primary auditory cortex in deaf people responded even more to
>> touch than to vision.
>> 
>> The researchers took advantage of a known perceptual illusion in
>> hearing people to look at how deaf brains processed both touch and
>> vision together. The auditory-induced double-flash is a phenomenon in
>> which a single flash of light, paired with two or more brief sounds,
>> is perceived as multiple flashes of light. The researchers modified
>> the illusion for their experiment by using a double puff of air as a
>> tactile stimulus to replace the auditory stimulus. Deaf people were
>> susceptible to the illusion of a double flash of light when a single
>> flash was paired with double air puffs; hearing people were not.
>> 
>> The deaf participants all showed greater activity in Heschl's gyrus in
>> response to the air puffs and light, but their responses differed in
>> degree. Those with the highest level of auditory cortex activity in
>> response to touch also had the strongest response to the illusion.
>> This supports the interpretation that the double-flash illusion is a
>> functional consequence of the altered cross-modal organization in the
>> deaf brain.
>> 
>> Cross-modal plasticity can cause problems. If the brain has
>> reorganized itself to compensate for the loss of hearing, what happens
>> when hearing is restored? Stephen Lomber, a psychologist who studies
>> cross-modal plasticity at the University of Western Ontario, compares
>> it to a cottage you aren't using, so you let a friend stay there. The
>> friend gets comfortable, rearranges the furniture, and settles in. If
>> you come back, they may not want to leave. This could be why older
>> people who are partially deaf find hearing aids confusing or
>> unhelpful.
>> 
>> Cross-modal reorganization may also interfere with the success of
>> cochlear implants. Incomplete reversal of deafness-induced brain
>> reorganization might limit the benefit from cochlear implants,
>> especially in children born deaf who receive implants after the age of
>> four. These children, who have lacked auditory input since birth, may
>> struggle with language comprehension and speech because the auditory
>> areas of their brain have taken on the processing of other senses.
>> Karns and other researchers studying cross-modal plasticity hope a
>> better understanding of how the brain reorganizes will ultimately help
>> deaf people. The ability to measure how much the auditory cortex has
>> been repurposed for other sensory processing could help in designing
>> intervention programs to retrain the auditory cortex to process sounds
>> again. This research will not produce a real-life Daredevil, but it is
>> a reminder that our brains have some hidden superpowers.
>> 
>> Are you a scientist who specializes in neuroscience, cognitive
>> science, or psychology? And have you read a recent peer-reviewed paper
>> that you would like to write about? Please send suggestions to Mind
>> Matters editor Gareth Cook, a Pulitzer prize-winning journalist at the
>> Boston Globe. He can be reached at garethideas AT gmail.com or Twitter
>> @garethideas.
>> 
>> YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to
>> continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the
>> one-year subscription.
>> 
>> 
>> Email Address
>> Name
>> Scientific American is a trademark of Scientific American, Inc., used
>> with permission
>> 
>> © 2012 Scientific American, a Division of Nature America, Inc.
>> View Mobile Site
>> All Rights Reserved.
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> Advertise About Scientific American Subscribe Special Ad Sections
>> Press Room Renew Your Subscription Science Jobs Site Map Buy Back
>> Issues Partner Network Terms of Use Products & Services International
>> Editions Privacy Policy Subscriber Customer Service Contact Us Use of
>> Cookies Email this Article
>> Superpowers for the Blind and Deaf
>> 
>> Your Email Address
>> Recipient's Email Address (separate multiple addresses with a comma)
>> Comment (optional)
>> X  Subscribe Today
>> Save 66% off the cover price and get a free gift!
>> 
>> Learn More >>
>> 
>> X Please Log In
>> Email
>> Password
>> Forgot: Password
>> 
>> 
>> X Account Linking
>> Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?
>> 
>> --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>> 
>> Yes, please link my existing account with for quick, secure access.
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> s
>> Email
>> Password
>> 
>> 
>> Forgot Password?
>> No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.
>> 
>> Create Account X Report Abuse
>> Are you sure?
>> 
>> 
>> X Institutional Access
>> It has been identified that the institution you are trying to access
>> this article from has institutional site license access to Scientific
>> American on nature.com. To access this article in its entirety through
>> site license access, click below.
>> 
>> 
>> Site license access X Error
>> 
>> X Share this Article
>> StumbleUpon Digg Reddit Facebook Slashdot Fark RT @SciAm Superpowers
>> for the Blind and Deaf Twitter X
>> 
>> -- 
>> Deb's Cell:  520-225-8244
>> __________________________________
>> 
> 
> 
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> 
>> _______________________________________________
>> Wcb-l mailing list
>> Wcb-l at wcbinfo.org
>> http://wcbinfo.org/mailman/listinfo/wcb-l_wcbinfo.org
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Wcb-l mailing list
> Wcb-l at wcbinfo.org
> http://wcbinfo.org/mailman/listinfo/wcb-l_wcbinfo.org
_______________________________________________
nfbwatlk mailing list
nfbwatlk at nfbnet.org
http://nfbnet.org/mailman/listinfo/nfbwatlk_nfbnet.org
To unsubscribe, change your list options or get your account info for nfbwatlk:
http://nfbnet.org/mailman/options/nfbwatlk_nfbnet.org/bennett.prows%40hhs.gov